Lagman hails SC ruling on unprogrammed funds
By Rhaydz Barcia
LEGAZPI CITY --- Albay 1st District Rep. Krisel Lagman has welcomed the Supreme Court’s landmark ruling on unprogrammed appropriations, saying it upholds the constitutional principles her late father, former Rep. Edcel Lagman, sought to defend in challenging the national budget.
“The Supreme Court has spoken,” Krisel said, lauding the High Court’s decision on the petition filed by her father questioning the substantial increase in unprogrammed appropriations under the 2024 General Appropriations Act (GAA).
The petition challenged the increase in unprogrammed appropriations from P281.9 billion in the President’s National Expenditure Program (NEP) to P731.4 billion in the enacted 2024 GAA, or an increase of P449.5 billion. Meanwhile, programmed appropriations remained unchanged at P4.0198 trillion.
In its decision dated Oct. 7, 2026, and released on Oct. 20, the Supreme Court en banc ruled on Rep. Edcel C. Lagman, et al. v. The Congress of the Philippines, et al., G.R. No. 271059. The Court declared unconstitutional the 2024 and 2025 GAAs, or Republic Acts 11975 and 12116, respectively, and permanently prohibited the implementation of the fiscal triggers for unprogrammed appropriations under the 2026 GAA, or Republic Act 12314.
The Court observed that unprogrammed appropriations had evolved from a limited standby authority, contingent on the availability of additional revenues, into a funding mechanism for projects and programs that Congress had deprioritized.
It warned that this practice could allow Congress to effectively alter the national budget that the Constitution mandates the Executive to formulate.
The ruling established four conditions for valid unprogrammed appropriations moving forward: the prohibition of lump-sum allocations; clear distinctions between the conditions for using new income for programmed and unprogrammed expenditures, with new funds presumptively directed toward programmed expenditures; sufficient standards for prioritizing expenditures when multiple purposes are involved; and consistency with the national fiscal program and the limited, contingent nature of unprogrammed appropriations.
For Krisel, the decision affirms the position taken by her late father in questioning the substantial increase in unprogrammed funds beyond the amount proposed by the President.
Opposes 2026 budget
Despite the procedural and substantive reforms introduced in the proposed 2026 national budget, Krisel voted against House Bill No. 4058, citing continuing concerns over the practice of unprogrammed appropriations.
She maintained that the government must prevent a recurrence of what she described as the misuse of the funding mechanism.
“Offhand, I would personally opt for the scrapping of unprogrammed appropriations altogether. In the case of the 2024 and 2025 GAAs, the insertions were made during the bicameral conference committee deliberations,” she said.
She added that a supplemental budget could provide a more balanced approach to addressing contingencies, allowing the government to respond promptly while preserving legislative scrutiny.
“Just the same, to avoid arbitrariness inherent in an unprogrammed appropriations scheme, in the event of a contingency, a supplemental budget affords a good balance of speed and deliberation in addressing the challenge of the contingency. The congressional power of the purse must be asserted, but asserted judiciously,” she said.
Krisel stressed that the ruling should prompt lawmakers to reconsider how unprogrammed funds are incorporated into the national budget.
“The highest court of the land has unequivocally spoken — unprogrammed funds in the GAA, as currently practiced, are contrary to the Constitution. We should not perpetuate an errant interpretation of the Constitution with respect to unprogrammed funds because the inordinately huge increase in these funds can and will be the sanctuary of partisan and pet projects of some legislators,” she said.
Four consolidated petitions
Krisel said four consolidated petitions were originally filed before the Supreme Court challenging the 2024, 2025, and 2026 national budgets.
These were filed by her late father, who was eventually substituted by Krisel; Rep. Mujiv Hataman; Sen. Aquilino “Koko” Pimentel III and Rep. Pantaleon Alvarez; the Filipinos for Peace, Justice and Progress Movement Inc.; and Reps. Edgar Erice and Leila de Lima.
She explained that her father’s petition did not challenge the entire GAA, as the programmed appropriations were not the subject of his constitutional objection.
Instead, the petition focused on the amount by which unprogrammed appropriations exceeded the President’s proposed allocation.
According to Krisel, her father recognized the need to bring the issue before the Supreme Court to address what he considered a constitutional infirmity in the national budget and establish clearer guidance for the Executive and Congress in future budget deliberations.
She also clarified that the petition specifically questioned the increase made during the bicameral conference committee process, rather than placing responsibility solely on the House of Representatives or the Senate.
The bicameral conference committee is tasked with reconciling differences between the versions of a proposed measure approved by the House and the Senate. Although the committee’s report must be approved by both chambers, the committee’s role in increasing the unprogrammed appropriations was central to the challenge.
The Supreme Court’s ruling, however, did not declare unprogrammed appropriations unconstitutional in themselves. Rather, it established safeguards intended to ensure that these allocations remain consistent with constitutional requirements and the principles of fiscal discipline, transparency, and accountability.
Krisel also expressed gratitude to her brother, former Albay governor Edcel “Grex” Lagman, and Atty. Elmar Barreda for their work in defending the petition before the Supreme Court and supporting their late father’s advocacy for the Constitution and the rule of law.














Comments