MAGNIFICA HUMANITAS IN THE AGE OF CHATGPT: Part II — The Responsibility of Those Who Preach

Not all priests are created equal. They differ in gifts, experience, preparation, and circumstances. Some communicate easily; others struggle. Some are seasoned pastors; others are newly ordained. Many carry heavy workloads.
We should not romanticize an unprepared priest or condemn an exhausted one. Yet the faithful expect a homily that helps them understand God’s Word and its meaning in their lives.
A Homily Is More Than a Speech
Cardinal Luis Antonio Tagle’s admonition about using artificial intelligence to prepare homilies raises an important question: What makes a homily meaningful?
Having sat through thousands of homilies, I have had mixed experiences.
A homily must come from the heart and engage the mind. We have been gifted with both. Preaching requires scriptural understanding, prayer, and pastoral sensitivity.
Preparation begins with the readings speaking to the priest. The first reading from Wisdom invites the search for wisdom. He, too, must ask: Am I still seeking it? Am I allowing the Word to challenge me? Standing at the pulpit does not place him above its message. What wisdom can I bring to its interpretation? The priest does not add wisdom to the Gospel; he brings the discernment needed to unlock its meaning.
Consider last Sunday’s Liturgy of the Word, November 8, 2026: Wisdom invites us to seek wisdom; the psalm expresses our thirst for God; St. Paul offers resurrection hope; and the Ten Virgins call us to readiness. The homilist must find their connecting thread.
That requires more than retelling the Gospel. Why does the bridegroom delay? Why do all ten attendants fall asleep, including the wise ones? The parable does not condemn sleep; it asks whether preparation can endure delay. What does the oil signify? Why can the wise not share theirs? Spiritual readiness cannot be improvised or borrowed.
The Parable of the Sower can illuminate this message: the Word must take root and bear fruit; we cannot wait until harvest to cultivate the soil. A preacher cannot presume where the seed will grow. The Church is not a gathering of the perfect, but a community in need of mercy. The preacher sows with conviction and leaves room for grace.
This also invites us to look differently at young people leaving the Church. We should not presume they lack faith or compare them to the foolish virgins. Perhaps they carry their own kind of oil: curiosity, idealism, a thirst for transparency, and an expectation of accountability. Some have been alienated by clergy scandals and the Church’s handling of them. They see a painful gap between the Gospel preached and the conduct of those entrusted to proclaim it. Their questions deserve to be heard.
The parable does not define the oil this way; this is a contemporary analogy. But it raises a question: Has the Church recognized the gifts young people bring, listened to their concerns, and helped them keep their lamps burning?
The Beatitudes offer a glimpse of the Kingdom. When we comfort those who mourn, show mercy, defend the vulnerable, speak truth to power, or make peace, we make its values visible. We can become so focused on Christ’s return and final judgment that we fail to recognize Him before us. In Navy terms, this is situational awareness: recognizing what is happening and responding.
A priest must walk the talk. He does not merely preach the Gospel; he must make it visible in the way he lives and serves.
The homilist must do more than explain Scripture: he must touch lives, challenge assumptions, and help people grow. He also learns in preparing; he is not merely a teacher before learners, but a learner before the Word.
Where AI Can Help—and Where It Cannot
AI can examine context, explore connections, compare interpretations, and raise questions. The priest must verify its suggestions and discern what is faithful to Scripture and relevant to his congregation.
AI cannot know a family’s grief, a parent’s anxiety, or the suffering of someone forgotten. It can describe these experiences, but has not lived them. The priest brings wisdom from study, prayer, conversion, and pastoral encounters.
AI may help a priest find the words. But only a human being can give those words the meaning that comes from faith, compassion, experience, and love.
The Church’s Responsibility
Formation cannot end at ordination. Young priests need mentors and opportunities to observe, prepare, receive feedback, and gradually assume pastoral responsibilities. Mentorship should mean learning to shepherd alongside a shepherd.
The Church must provide continuing intellectual, spiritual, and pastoral formation—not merely on paper, but through practical mentoring. A shortage makes this urgent: overburdened priests need support; younger priests need guidance.
Many of us who grew up in the Philippines inherited faith through our parents’ prayers and example. We were taught to listen to the priest; asking questions was not always encouraged. Today, access to Scripture and other resources lets the faithful explore their faith more deeply.
The Ten Virgins remind us that we may inherit prayers and traditions, but not another person’s spiritual readiness. The wise could not transfer their oil. Faith may be passed down, but it must become our own. The pulpit should begin a conversation, helping the faithful understand, question, reflect, and live the Word—a responsibility we will explore in Part III.
The global flock does not need perfect robots in the pulpit. It needs real, fragile human beings who, despite fatigue, give what spirit they have left to the people they love.
The cracks are where the Holy Spirit enters.
AI may assist the preacher’s mind, but it cannot replace the preacher’s heart, conscience, or pastoral responsibility. A homily must be prepared by the mind, nourished by the heart, and made meaningful through the life of the person who delivers it.














Comments